MortgageInfo.us 30-yr 7.11%

Home equity

Keep your low mortgage rate: why a HELOC can beat a cash-out refinance in 2026

If your first mortgage has a rate below 5%, replacing it with a 7%+ cash-out refinance can cost far more than borrowing only what you need through a HELOC or home equity loan. See the math side by side.

The short answer

If your current mortgage rate is well below today's rates, a HELOC or home equity loan usually costs less than a cash-out refinance because only the new money is priced at today's higher rate. A cash-out refinance reprices your entire balance, so you give up your low rate on money you were already borrowing cheaply.

Free to quote with a link back.

Estimate the payment: the HELOC payment calculator shows draw-period and repayment payments.

Why are so many homeowners reluctant to refinance?

Millions of homeowners locked in fixed rates between 2020 and 2022 at 3% to 4%. With the 30-year average now at 7.03%, giving that up is expensive. But many of those same owners have built substantial equity and want to use some of it for a renovation, education costs, or paying off higher-interest debt. The question is how to get that cash without losing the low rate.

What is the core difference?

A cash-out refinance replaces your entire first mortgage with a new, larger one. Every dollar, including the balance you already owed, is now priced at today's rate. A HELOC or home equity loan is a separate second loan. Your original mortgage stays in place at its low rate, and only the new borrowing carries the higher rate.

Side-by-side example

Scenario

You have a 30-year, $300,000 mortgage at 3.25% from four years ago. The balance is about $274,760 and your payment is $1,306. You need $60,000 for a kitchen renovation. Assume a cash-out refinance at 7.03% and a home equity loan at 8.5% over 15 years.

Cash-out refinanceKeep the loan and add a home equity loan
New borrowing$334,760 new first mortgage (30 years at 7.03%)$60,000 second loan (15 years at 8.5%)
Rate on the original $274,7607.03%3.25% (unchanged)
Combined monthly paymentAbout $2,234About $1,896 ($1,306 + $591)
Interest paid over the remaining lifeAbout $469,000About $179,000 (remaining first-mortgage interest of about $133,000 plus about $46,000 on the second loan)
Closing costsTypically 2% to 5% of the new loan, about $6,700 to $16,700Typically a few hundred dollars to a couple of thousand

In this example the cash-out refinance costs about $338 more per month and roughly $290,000 more in lifetime interest, mostly because the original $275,000 is now borrowed at 7.03% instead of 3.25%. (The refinance also restarts a 30-year term, which stretches interest over more years. That is part of the difference, but even on equal terms the rate gap dominates.)

HELOC or home equity loan: which second loan?

  • Home equity loan: a lump sum at a fixed rate with equal monthly payments. Good when you know the amount you need, such as a renovation with a contract price.
  • HELOC: a revolving credit line with a variable rate. Good when costs are spread out over time, and you want to borrow only what you use. Interest-only payments are typical during the draw period, but the rate can rise. Compare them in detail.
HELOC payment example

A $60,000 HELOC balance at 8% costs $400 a month interest-only. If the rate rose to 9% and the balance were repaid over 20 years, the payment would be about $540. HELOC rates follow the prime rate, which moves with the Federal Reserve. What the September Fed hike means.

When does a cash-out refinance still make sense?

  • Your current rate is at or above today's market rate.
  • You need a large amount relative to the value of your home, and a HELOC lender will not offer enough.
  • You have an adjustable-rate loan or high-cost mortgage insurance you want to eliminate at the same time.
  • You want one predictable payment and are comfortable with the tradeoffs.

Read the details in our cash-out refinance guide.

Risks to weigh with any home equity borrowing

  • Your home is collateral. Missing payments on a second loan can lead to foreclosure on the property, even if your first mortgage is current.
  • Variable-rate risk on HELOCs. Payments can rise with rate increases and when the draw period ends.
  • Total leverage. Most lenders cap combined loans at 80% to 90% of home value. Borrowing right up to the limit leaves little cushion if home prices dip.
  • Use of funds. Borrowing against your home for spending that does not build value or reduce higher-cost debt can turn into a long-term burden. Read our full home equity guide.

How to compare offers

  1. Get the current rate and margin (for a HELOC) or fixed rate (for a home equity loan), plus any annual fee, early-closure fee, and closing costs.
  2. Ask for the maximum combined loan-to-value the lender allows.
  3. Ask what the HELOC payment will be after the draw period ends.
  4. Compare the total monthly payment and lifetime interest of each path, as in the table above.

Debt consolidation math: card balances vs. a HELOC

Paying off high-interest credit cards is one of the most common reasons to borrow against home equity. The interest savings can be large, but they depend on discipline.

Example

You owe $30,000 across credit cards at 22% APR and can afford $900 a month. Paying the cards takes about 52 months and costs about $16,800 in interest. Borrowing $30,000 on a HELOC at 8.5% and paying the same $900 a month takes about 39 months and costs about $4,300 in interest. The savings are about $12,400 and 13 months. The risk is that the debt is now secured by your home, and if the cards are run up again, you carry both.

How much should you borrow?

  • Borrow the amount you need, not the maximum offered. Unused HELOC capacity costs nothing (apart from any annual fee).
  • Keep combined loan-to-value at a level that leaves a cushion if prices fall, for example 70% to 75% instead of the 85% or 90% some lenders allow.
  • Choose a repayment plan before you borrow, and treat the HELOC's interest-only option as a floor, not a target.

Checklist before opening a HELOC or home equity loan

  1. Confirm your first mortgage rate and remaining balance.
  2. Estimate your home's value and combined loan-to-value.
  3. Get quotes from at least three lenders, including a credit union.
  4. Ask about the margin, rate cap, annual fee, early-closure fee, and fixed-rate conversion options.
  5. Calculate the payment during the draw and repayment periods at the current rate and at a rate 2 points higher.
  6. Confirm that your budget can handle the higher payment.

Is a personal loan a better idea?

Sometimes. Personal loans are unsecured, so your home is not at risk, and they can close quickly. Rates are higher than on home equity loans, especially for borrowers with lower credit scores. For amounts under about $30,000 and short terms, the difference in interest can be modest compared with the value of not putting the home on the line. For larger amounts or longer terms, home equity borrowing generally costs less.

Frequently asked questions

Is a HELOC better than a cash-out refinance?

If your first mortgage rate is well below current rates, usually yes, because you keep that low rate on your existing balance. If your rate is at or above today's rate, a cash-out refinance may be simpler and cheaper.

Do HELOC rates go up when the Fed raises rates?

Most HELOCs are tied to the prime rate, which moves with the Federal Reserve's target rate, so HELOC rates typically rise soon after a Fed increase.

How much can I borrow with a HELOC?

Usually up to a combined loan-to-value of 80% to 90%, minus what you owe on your first mortgage.

Are closing costs lower on a HELOC?

Often. Many HELOCs have low or waived closing costs, though some charge an annual fee or an early-closure fee.

Can I lock the rate on a HELOC?

Some lenders allow you to convert part of the balance to a fixed rate. Ask before you sign.